DAVID BIANCULLI

Founder / Editor

ERIC GOULD

Associate Editor

LINDA DONOVAN

Assistant Editor

Contributors

ALEX STRACHAN

MIKE HUGHES

KIM AKASS

MONIQUE NAZARETH

ROGER CATLIN

GARY EDGERTON

TOM BRINKMOELLER

GERALD JORDAN

NOEL HOLSTON

 
 
 
 
 
'The Killing': AMC's Latest Dark, Daring TV Triumph
April 2, 2011  | By David Bianculli
 
killing-trunk.jpg

Of all the special TV events vying for attention Sunday -- including the launch of Showtime's The Borgias and the opening installment of the orphaned, adopted miniseries The Kennedys -- the most compelling and impressive is also the darkest. It's The Killing, the newest bold programming move by AMC...

The Killing, premiering Sunday at 9 p.m. ET on AMC, is based on a 2007 Denmark miniseries named Forbrydelsen, which probed the murder of a local high-school girl from three different perspectives: the detectives investigating the case, the parents of the victim, and a politician who may or may not be implicated in the murder. Each hour of the miniseries represents a day in the investigation, as the cops weave their way through a gauntlet of puzzling clues, evasive suspects, and unsatisfactory answers.

For the U.S. audience, the show has been reworked (by Veena Sud, upping her game from the more formulaic Cold Case and the quirkier but less satisfying Push, Nevada), transplanted (to Seattle, though it's actually shot in Vancouver), and recast -- and recast very, very well.

killing-michelle-forbes-.jpg

Quality TV viewers are bound to recognize, and welcome, Michelle Forbes (Homicide: Life on the Street, True Blood), who plays the mother of the slain Rosie Larsen, and Billy Campbell (Once and Again), who plays mayoral candidate Darren Richmond.

But the stars in the making in The Killing are Mireille Enos as Sarah Linden, the homicide detective whose last day on the job becomes complicated by the discovery of Rosie's body -- and Sarah's replacement, Joel Kinnamon's Stephen Holder, who arrives to take Sarah's place, but stays on as her temporary, very unorthodox partner.

KILLING-duo.jpg

Kinnamon is a Swedish actor just recently arriving in the Americas, and his role here is a standout -- kind of like Columbo as a sly slacker. But Enos, who did double duty playing the twins on Big Love, gets an even bigger chance to shine here. Amid all the gloominess, she's luminous, reflecting the tender soul and quiet determination of a cop who's always questioning, but always caring.

The Killing is extremely, intentionally slow-paced, and relentlessly dark. It's a little like Twin Peaks without the comic relief, and its characters, pace and focus may remind you of other landmark TV series as well. (For a full rundown, read, or listen to, my review of The Killing on NPR's Fresh Air with Terry Gross, by clicking HERE.)

But as dark and deliberate as it is, it's also haunting, involving and unshakeable. You care about these people, and certainly care about what happens next. It may not sound like the sort of TV entertainment you want to cozy up to -- but think of it: Did Breaking Bad? Did The Walking Dead?

Yet by exploring its dark side, AMC has come up with yet another bright jewel in TV's crown. To sample it for yourself, here's a four-minute preview from AMC. It's spoiler-free, but gives a very good sense of the show's tone and quality...



14 Comments

 

Eileen said:

This looks terrific. So happy you reviewed it, but I was sure you would with all the positive buzz it's gotten.

Whatever went on in the negotiations between AMC & Mad Men, you still have to give AMC a lot of credit. Who would have thought a few years ago that we would all be singing their praises for some of the best and most innovative programming on any station, cable or commercial. For that we all owe AMC a big thank you.

On with the show...

Comment posted on April 2, 2011 10:53 AM


Ike Moses said:

Great, another AMC show for me to fall in love with and mourn when it gets canceled for being too excellent. Rubicon, RIP.

[I'm right with you. And I'm STILL in mourning for the premature death of Deadwood. Sigh. -- DB]

Comment posted on April 2, 2011 4:40 PM


Deb said:

Good movie, however poor quality. The film is black. I can't make out what is going on. On the movie it is constantly raining and everyone on different scenes look like they lost their electricity. Come on AMC, I would watch more of your movies, if you put more light on the scenes.

Comment posted on April 3, 2011 10:16 PM


jan said:

I'm really liking it so far--much more than I usually do American remakes--but I would also like to see the Danish original. I understand it played in England in the original. Any chance that BBC America will have it on and/or put out DVDs for region 1 of the original? I don't have an all region player, but maybe I should get one. Too many good things on foreign TV that I want to see (and that I DON'T want to see the American remake of: Life on Mars, Skins. At least we finally got the DVDs of those.)It reminds me more of Durham County than anything else so far, and I love the music and the dark, wet atmosphere. (And BTW, besides Deadwood and Rubicon, add Terriers to the list of shows I'm still mourning which were cancelled before their time. And Rome.)

[I haven't looked into this yet, but I will, soon. Guaranteed -- the original version from Denmark will surface soon. I'll keep you posted. -- DB]

Comment posted on April 4, 2011 10:11 AM


3Carols said:

I. Love. This. Show.

And I did't even recognize Mireille Enos from Big Love, it was bugging me that she was very familiar but the context was SO different I couldn't make the connection. Great acting by the whole cast.

[I. Agree. With. You. Completely. - DB]

Comment posted on April 5, 2011 8:01 PM


Mark K Mondol said:

I finally started watching the AMC version of The Killing last night. Having just finished watching the BBC replay of the original Danish production I was really impressed with the AMC product. It is much like the original: some scences virtually identical, same plot so far, same characters but with differing interpretations. They seem so American after the brooding, less talkative and more introspective Danish characters of the original. Sarah seems much more sexual, the new detective Stephen so boyish and punky, the parents of Rosie more acceptably "pretty". It all seems to work well in the context. The colour pallette is flat and washed out, different than the very dark and saturated Danish original, but the cinematography is excellent in both. I ended up watching the first 20 minutes twice; the second time around the somewhat forced plot exposition and the later political thread seem radically shortened which I assume is the result of taking about 19 full hours of TV and turning them into 13 episodes that run for 48 (?) minutes each. I am really looking forward to seeing it play out, even though I know how it ends (or at least I know how the Danish one ends).

[Thanks SO much for this. I haven't seen the original version yet, and am thrilled to hear that, in your estimation, it's a worthy adaptation. -- DB]

Comment posted on April 8, 2011 3:39 PM


Danny said:

I think I will like this series....with the exception of it being so dark. I agree with Deb. Turn on the lights.

Comment posted on April 10, 2011 7:52 PM


Darkmetal said:

I agree totally with the "Twin Peaks" comparison, but would also say I sense a bit of "The Silence of the Lambs" as well--female detective looks into the life of murdered young woman with all its modern sexuality and the specter of drug use.

Right now we are early on in this series, so I suspect that we cannot determine the murderer. However, we can make some assumptions:

1. The politician may be a bit of a naive patsy, but I doubt he did it. I suspect darker elements in the campaign that he is unaware of. I think the one who leaked info was not the male staffer, but actually his blonde gf. Does she have some motivation to destroy him? What better way than to put a body in a trunk of a campaign car.

2. The former bf and the drugger are unlikely killers, it is too obvious. They may have raped Rosie, but I don't think they killed her. However, the amount of blood on the mattress in "the cage" seems like too much for a living person, but the Lead detective says Rosie died "of drowning". Hmm, not blood loss?

3. Something about the Detective "Partner" bugs me. He alternates between being a goof one minute, and a surprisingly good undercover investigator the next. But in the latest episode, he says he is using fake marijuana to get "inside" but when he gives the two girls a toke in EP 1, they say, "Wow, that is good stuff". This means he is not telling the truth to the lead detective.

4. Why have the parents not been interviewed? Wouldn't that be the first place to check? Is the father as deeply sad as he appears? He looks genuine, but sociopaths can look that way as well.

[The parents will continue to be looked at -- and since this entire series, in its original incarnation, exists already, predicting plot points shows an extreme faith in spoiler alerts. But it's good to have the debate here, and a new reader, so hello. For future reference, a polite request, please: around here at TVWW, we take the extra seconds to spell out abbreviations like boyfriend and girlfriend. Thanks. TTFN! -- DB]

Comment posted on April 11, 2011 9:45 AM


Terry said:

The Parents
The parents' alibi was checked: their car didn't leave the campground all weekend. That seemed to close the case against the parents, but since most murders are committed by family members, I wonder why that wasn't checked into more thoroughly.

The Politician: Darren Richmond
We have yet to learn about the "trips" he took that weren't "a matter of public record." A woman called Meg or Mig called Richmond about them.

The Campaign Workers
Clearly someone there is leaking information. The initial check on emails going out points to Jamie, the manager, but he did protest. It could be Gwen the adviser sent an email using Jamie's account.

The Kids
Yeah, they raped Rosie. We have yet to learn what all the blood in the cage was about though. That was A LOT of blood. Or is it blood at all? The last school event was a Halloween party.

Belko, the Father's Co-Worker
I like him for the murder, because we have seen very little of him but he seems to have access to the Larsens. It's possible that Rosie called him after the rapes. It's also possible that Rosie was involved with this guy, and that he's the reason she's got the very expensive high-heeled shoes.

The Current Mayor
I don't see it. But who knows?

Comment posted on April 12, 2011 12:25 PM


Max said:

Saw the pilot and part 2 this morning at 6am; I love this show; the detail of the writing took my breath away. I realized how deep this show is when I saw Jack spitting into the water, and how much effort the parents went into keeping the day 'normal' until they could no longer. (So much more, but so little space, and I'm not a fast typist.)

[Take your time. We'll be here. -- DB]

Comment posted on April 17, 2011 5:44 PM


Shoot the Critic said:

Hey,
I agree with many of your comments. I too compared this show to Twin Peaks, also noting The Killing's lack of sense of humor, so crucial to the greatness of David Lynch's series.
But I'm totally with you about Kinnamon. I really like his character and I'm glad he's there, an idiosyncratic choice in the midst of the usual (though fine) suspects -- such as the grieving mother, the morally questionable father, the dedicated and emotional female detective, etc.
I was very excited about this series and I'm liking how it's going. Things are really developing and, while new details are being added regarding the case, the investigation seems to be getting more complex and less clear as to an end "result."
I reviewed it here: http://shootthecritic.com/guide/tv/the_killing. And blogged about it on my film&tv web site, http://shootthecritic.com.

Check it out, if you'd like.

[I liked your blog enough to forward this link. Good luck with it -- and welcome to the critical fraternity. - DB]
- Shoot the Critic

Comment posted on April 18, 2011 11:21 PM


Camille Warring said:

The Danish version is absolutely addictive. It is so good that I can't stop watching it. With each episode the plot changes and just when you think you have a clue the whole senerio changes. I watch 2 episodes a night and can't wait to watch the next. What a very different and entertaining series..

[Thanks for the encouragement, Camille. I'm just about to order the Danish. Which I usually do, but only in a diner. -- DB]

Comment posted on June 6, 2011 9:17 AM


Max said:

I was planning on watching the Danish, but I can't now. I fell for this show, hook, etc. I audibly gasped at ep12, and my face dropped in THOSE LAST FEW MINUTES.

Now I must rewatch and start looking for details; like does the car that Holder was in at the end have tinted windows? If not, then he's working for, or setting up someone else. Of course Richmond is not the guy.

Here we go, ep 1...

Comment posted on June 22, 2011 9:49 PM


Eric Robinson said:

Was I the only one that enjoyed the final episode of this show? Everyone seems to have turned against it ever since the finale.

[I think you may well have been. But that's okay. As a TV critic, I find myself standing alone, a lot. - DB]

Comment posted on December 16, 2011 12:32 AM
 
 
 
 
 
Leave a Comment: (No HTML, 1000 chars max)
 
 Name (required)
 
 Email (required) (will not be published)
 
LHHWE
Type in the verification word shown on the image.