Fox's 'Mindy Project' an Uneven Work in Progress
Having left The Office behind after eight years as Kelly Kapoor, here's Mindy Kaling in her very own show.
First impression: The Mindy Project, taking up residence on Fox's new all-comedy Tuesday nights (beginning Sept. 25 at 9:30 p.m. ET), is a minor disappointment in light of all the accomplished guest stars populating its opening half-hour.
There's Ed Helms, who's matriculated from The Office to the hit Hangover movies.
Saturday Night Live's current funniest male cast member, Bill Hader, also drops in. As does Richard Schiff of West Wing fame.
Another naturally amusing guy, Dallas native Stephen Tobolowsky (Groundhog Day), will have a piece of the Mindy pie as a cast regular. He's seen for only a smidge in the series premiere, though. Gotta make room for all those guest stars. And we're not even including the film clip glimpses of Meg Ryan, Tom Hanks and Billy Crystal. The star of the show also drops Sandra Bullock's name.
Kaling, whose birth name was Vera Chokalingham, plays an unlucky-in-love OB/GYN named Mindy Lahiri. Much of her adolescent and adult life has been spent yearning for a happy ending from one of the big-screen romantic comedies she watches incessantly. But in the early narrative-driven minutes of Mindy, she loses her guy (played by Hader) to a Serbian "bagel girl" with notably bad teeth. Which he fixes before marrying her.
Mindy ends up making a scene at their wedding reception, a comedy device also used in the first episode of Fox's other new Tuesday nighter, Ben and Kate. Then she steals a bike, proclaims "I'm Sandra Bullock," crashes into a pool and sees a Barbie doll at the bottom telling her to get her life together. Next you know she's in handcuffs. It's a lot to swallow.
None of this meshes all that well, but Tuesday's premiere episode is buoyed down the stretch by Mindy's blind date with Dennis (Helms), whom she prays has "the penis of Michael Fassbender."
Helms plays a sweet guy in the face of Mindy's free-form riffs, which are cut short when she's called back to the hospital. Even so, their brief time together is pretty savory.
Kaling and her co-writers may figure all of this out in time — provided they get enough time. For starters, though, The Mindy Project is the weakest entry in a revamped Fox Tuesday lineup that also includes the aforementioned Ben and Kate plus returnees New Girl and Raising Hope. That combination raises the bar, which Kaling is capable of reaching with more focus and less scattershooting.
GRADE: C+
Read more by Ed Bark at unclebarky.com